How to choose a camshaft

Jump to: navigation, search
(Add image)
(How these things affect an engine's output: Add text, link; clean up)
Line 47: Line 47:
 
The following is a rough guide to how the cam specs relates to how the cam is used:
 
The following is a rough guide to how the cam specs relates to how the cam is used:
  
*Stock/near stock cam: 0.260" to 0.273” lobe lift (0.390” to 0.410” lift w/1.5 rockers); duration @ 0.050” lift around 200°  
+
*Stock/near stock cam: 0.260" to 0.273” lobe lift (0.390” to 0.410” lift w/1.5 rockers); duration @ 0.050” lift around 180° to 200°  
*RV/mild performance cam: 0.300 to 0.307" (0.450” to 0.460” lift w/1.5 rockers); duration @ 0.050” lift around 212° to 222°  
+
*RV/mild performance cam: 0.300 to 0.310" lobe lift (0.450” to 0.465” lift w/1.5 rockers); duration @ 0.050” lift around 212° to 222°  
*Hot street performance cam: 0.320" or so lobe lift (around 0.480” lift w/1.5 rockers); duration @ 0.050 lift around 230°  
+
*Hot street performance cam: 0.320" or so lobe lift (0.460" to 0.480” lift w/1.5 rockers); duration @ 0.050" lift around 230°  
*Racy street/strip: 0.333" or higher lobe lift (0.500”-plus lift w/1.5 rockers), duration @ 0.050” lift around 232°-up
+
*Racy street/strip cam: 0.333" and higher lobe lift (0.500” and higher lift w/1.5 rockers); duration @ 0.050” lift around 232° and higher
  
 
===Duration===
 
===Duration===
Increasing duration will tend to shift the power and torque curves upward.  Longer durations lend themselves to higher RPM operation, because at higher RPM the amount of time the valve spends open is smaller than at lower RPM.  Keeping the valves open longer allows the cylinders to fill with more air and fuel. Since the valve may be open considerably longer than the intake stroke, it does tend to reduce power and torque at lower RPM.  At lower RPM the intake valve is open too long for maximum efficiency, so the suffers. and some of the good stuff you just sucked in there gets pushed back out because the valve is open longer than optimal for low-RPM operation. Another important factor to remember is that larger engines tend to "tame down" a cam's duration.  The same duration cam in a small displacement engine will have a higher peak RPM than if you installed it in a larger displacement engine. For example, if a cam provides a 6500 RPM peak hp in a 305 Chevy, the same cam might peak its HP at 5500 in a 400 ChevyHere is a comparison between two engines.  The only thing I changed about these two simulations is the duration of the camshaft.  Notice that the engine with the larger cam makes more power, but you would have to rev it 1000 rpms faster to get it.  Notice also the huge loss of torque down low.  This is an extreme example just for comparison.
+
Increasing duration will tend to shift the power and torque curves upward.  Longer durations lend themselves to higher RPM operation, because at higher RPM the amount of time the valve spends open is less than at lower RPM.  Keeping the valves open longer allows the cylinders to fill with more air and fuel. Since the valve may be open considerably longer than the intake stroke, it does tend to reduce power and torque at lower RPM.  At lower RPM the intake valve is open too long for maximum efficiency, so the efficiency suffers because some of the air/fuel mixture gets pushed out with the exhaust, along with some a/f charge getting pushed back into the intake manifold (called "reversion").  
 +
 
 +
Another thing to remember is that larger engines tend to lessen the effect of having a longer duration.  The same duration cam in a small displacement engine will have a higher peak RPM than if it was installed in a larger displacement engine. For example, if a cam provides a 6500 RPM peak hp in a 305 SBC, the same cam might peak at 5500 in a 400 SBC.   
  
 
===Lift===
 
===Lift===
Lift is a number that is best matched to your heads.  Head flows for common American head castings can be found on the internet. They are flow tested and the numbers published at different lift levels. More lift is generally better provided two things are addressed: the valves, retainers, and springs are capable of the lift you plan without binding, and the heads flow more as you lift more.  If your heads start decreasing flow above .500" lift, there is no reason for .700" lift, but in most cases more is better up to the point where the heads start losing flow.  Since the aftermarket has plenty of rocker ratios available for most engines, the lift that is ground into the cam is usually sufficient, but shopping around between cam brands and product lines might yield slightly different lifts that you can use to fine tune. One more finer point about lift that I like to mention is ramp speed.  For a given duration, more lift means the lobe ramps (the opening and closing faces on the sides of the lobe) are more aggressive.  That is to say, they have to accelerate the lifter faster to get to the peak lift in the given duration.  Faster ramp speeds usually pay off big time because they get the valve lifted higher, faster.  The sooner you can get the heads flowing their peak air, the more air can get sucked in the cylinder. The downside for flat-tappet cams is that the steeper ramps mean they contact the lifter at a stronger angle.  The potential for wiping out a cam lobe or lifter is greater, but manufacturers know that and design ramps to be as fast as they can be without destroying components.
+
Lift is a number that is best matched to your cylinder heads.  Head flow for common domestic head castings can be found {http://users.erols.com/srweiss/tablehdc.htm '''here''']. Heads are flow tested at different lift levels, and at different amounts of "depression" (usually measured in in/Hg). When comparing heads, be sure the depression is similar, or be prepared to convert the results from one depression to another depression, using a calculator. Another difference that can be found when comparing head flow, is the size of the cylinder the head is sitting over, and yet another thing is whether an intake manifold is in place (rarely done), or if an exhaust tube is in place (more common), or is clay is used to radius the openings (fairly common).
 +
 
 +
More lift is generally better provided two things are addressed: the valves, retainers, and springs are capable of the lift you plan without binding, and the heads flow more as the valve is lifted higher.  If a head port starts decreasing flow above 0.500" lift, there is no reason to try to use a 0.700" lift cam, but in most cases more lift is better up to the point where the heads start losing flow.  Since the aftermarket has different rocker ratios available for most engines, the lobe lift of the cam can result in more lift than the stock ratio rockers would give.  
 +
 
 +
===Ramp speed/lobe intensity===
 +
One more point about the cam profile is ramp speed.  For a given duration, more lift means the lobe ramps (the opening and closing faces on the sides of the lobe) are steeper (more aggressive).  That is to say, the cam lobe has has to accelerate the lifter faster to get to the peak lift within the available amount of duration duration.  Faster ramp speed can give more "area under the curve", which usually equates to a broader, less peaky powerband. The downside for flat tappet cams is that the steeper ramps mean they contact the lifter at a greater angle, so the potential for wiping out a cam lobe or lifter is greater. Manufacturers are well aware of this, so they try to design the lobe profiles to optimize power, yet maintain good durability. Cam profiles like the Comp Cams XE-series and Lunati's Voodoo line are both at the edge of how fast the valve can be safely opened and closed. That's why they caution against using a higher ratio rocker arm when using these grinds.  
  
 
===Lobe separation angle (LSA)===
 
===Lobe separation angle (LSA)===
 
Lobe separation for a given duration will alter a few different things.  Primarily it changes the amount of overlap.  A narrower LSA will increase overlap.  This has a tendency to reduce engine output at lower RPM and increase engine output at higher RPM.  A narrower LSA tend to make more peak power but a little less average power.  A wider LSA tend to make less peak power, but a broader powerband.  Changing the LSA also changes the valve timing events; opening the exhaust valve sooner and closing the intake valve later, both of which affect how the engine ingests air.
 
Lobe separation for a given duration will alter a few different things.  Primarily it changes the amount of overlap.  A narrower LSA will increase overlap.  This has a tendency to reduce engine output at lower RPM and increase engine output at higher RPM.  A narrower LSA tend to make more peak power but a little less average power.  A wider LSA tend to make less peak power, but a broader powerband.  Changing the LSA also changes the valve timing events; opening the exhaust valve sooner and closing the intake valve later, both of which affect how the engine ingests air.
 +
 +
====Narrower LSA:====
 +
*Moves torque to lower RPM
 +
*Increases maximum torque
 +
*Narrow power band
 +
*Builds higher cylinder pressure
 +
*Increase chance of engine knock
 +
*Increase cranking compression
 +
*Increase effective compression
 +
*Idle vacuum is reduced
 +
*Idle quality suffers
 +
*Valve overlap Increases
 +
*Natural EGR effect increases
 +
*Decreases piston-to-valve clearance
 +
 +
====Wider LSA:====
 +
*Raise torque to higher RPM
 +
*Reduces maximum torque
 +
*Broadens power band
 +
*Reduce maximum cylinder pressure
 +
*Decrease chance of engine knock
 +
*Decrease cranking compression
 +
*Decrease effective compression
 +
*Idle vacuum is increased
 +
*Idle quality improves
 +
*Valve overlap decreases
 +
*Natural EGR effect is reduced
 +
*Increases piston-to-valve clearance
  
 
===Overlap===
 
===Overlap===

Revision as of 00:36, 7 June 2012

Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
Navigation
Categories
Toolbox